Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: When Dwyane Wade Lost His Cool

2012 MLS Draft: San Jose Earthquakes fill their need for speed with selection of U.C Santa Barbara forward Sam Garza

Sam Garza, resplendent in his San Jose Earthquakes draft day scarf, addresses the media after this selection sixth overall in the 2012 MLS SuperDraft.

Pursuing a need for increased team speed that head coach Frank Yallop revealed at the completion of the 2011 MLS regular season, the San Jose Earthquakes made dynamic winger Sam Garza their first selection in yesterday’s MLS SuperDraft. The Generation Adidas signing out of U.C. Santa Barbara was a surprise pick by many (sift through the complement of post-draft analyses listed after the break), but was a player the Earthquakes had targeted well before the pre-draft MLS Combine.

"I’ve always liked Sam," shared coach Yallop after the conclusion of the draft. "All of us on the coaching staff, we’ve had him scouted and liked what we saw. He’s very talented; he’s got good ability to beat players with or without the ball. He’s a good all-around player with a great attitude. It was a great selection for us."

With other comparable players available to the Earthquakes when they made their selection at number six overall, the decision to go with Garza came down to what television commentator Alexi Lalas referred to as "catnip to coaches" — speed. The UCSB standout finished with the second best sprint time at the MLS Combine, behind only undrafted High Point forward Karo Okiomah. In fact, Garza showed off his multidimensional skill set with a fifth place finish in the power vertical leap test as well.

"He’s very quick and dynamic," assessed Yallop. "He can play wide, he can play second forward, I think he can play a lot of positions, which is obviously good. The way he goes about things on the field, we are very excited to have him."

One of the biggest concerns for the Earthquakes in 2011 was the dearth of speed on the wings, which contributed to a stunted counterattack as well as an ability to break down defensives when settled into the offensive third. In a busy offseason, the Earthquakes have added speedy midfielders Shea Salinas and Marvin Chavez to the roster, in addition to the newly drafted Garza. Coach Yallop sees all three players playing a major role for the team in the 2012 season.

"If you look at the way we played toward the end of the season," said Yallop when asked where the new players fit into the squad, "we had guys like Simon Dawkins and Rafael Baca playing wide which is not their natural positions. They did a good job overall, but our service to the front men was not as good as it could be. We picked up Marvin Chavez and Shea Salinas, and now Garza, who are all natural wide players. It adds a dimension to what we are trying to do and overall well make the team well-rounded."

While the status of the proposed loan deal to bring Dawkins back to San Jose is still in discussion, coach Yallop did mention that he hoped the negotiations could be completed within the next week or two. The success of the Earthquakes offseason moves hinges in large degree to whether they can bring back the young Tottenham player. If Spurs and the Earthquakes are unable to make a deal work, San Jose will have to look elsewhere for a central attacking midfielder, or look inward to their own roster.

"I want a dynamic and quick player that can fit into our system," revealed Yallop on their current scouting activities. "I don’t care where he comes from, but he has to be able to match the way we want to play. We are still looking, and we are spending a lot of times watching games and going over potential guys, but it is not easy."

With training camp slated to open this Sunday, and the season opener less than two months away, time is not on the Earthquakes side to bring in that target player. If they are able to do so before the start of the season, and they are able to settle in with the team, the Earthquakes will be well on their way to taking the steps forward to put last year’s disappointing season behind them.

Star-divide

A look around the web to how others viewed the San Jose Earthquakes 2012 MLS Draft selecitons:

Ives Galarcep gives the Earthquakes a passing grade in his draft grades on FoxSoccer.com.

Travis Clark drops the Earthquakes into the losers category over at ESPN.com.

Charles Gooch on the scene for the Kansas City Star with a more objective look at the selections.

Simon Borg at MLSSoccer.com with a different look at the winners and losers.

Nicholas Rosano look at all three Earthquakes picks for CSN Bay Area.

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Rob, I am the biggest Yallop and Doyle supporter there is

so I am about as objective as it comes to evaluating them but they completely messed up the draft. I’m not screaming “fire yallop” or anything stupid over this but we are easily the biggest or second biggest losers of that draft. By any objective measure they completely screwed up. Even if you like Garza and Hustedt, why the hell would they burn a 2nd round pick on a keeper when we already have Busch and Bingham? 3rd keepers get zero playing time who cares about them… just wait until the supplemental rounds and get some cheap roster filler there like Brian Rowe. By doing that we missed out on getting Ray Gaddis, who some considered to be the best right back in the draft. And outside back depth is a wayyyyyy bigger need and more valuable position than THIRD KEEPER DEPTH. Are you freaking kidding me? I don’t even want to think about all the players we are going to miss out on in the supplemental draft b/c of this boneheaded move… we don’t even have a pick in the first round of it.

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Jan 13, 2012 4:17 PM PST reply actions  

As for Garza...
He’s a good all-around player

LOL no he is not. He is a mercurial and inconsistent winger who can’t pass very well and only had 4 assists last season. He does not defend well. He can score some good goals but is an inconsistent shooter and inconsistent finisher. He is fast as hell and a great athlete. He is definitely, definitely, 100%, not “well-rounded.” He has a few strengths and a lot of weaknesses.

The UCSB standout finished with the second best sprint time at the MLS Combine

Impressive. Sometimes speed can be enough to be productive in MLS. See Robbie Findley. Other times, it is not. See Shea Salinas. You have to look at the complete package in player evaluation, not just one aspect like speed. Why do they only rave about his speed? B/c that’s the only thing he’s got going for him.

If he was so good, why did he only score 8 goals and have 4 assists as a forward at the collegiate level. MLS is a big step up. I expect a #6 overall pick to have dominated college. Garza did not dominate. He did good but he’s not elite.

If they wanted speed so badly they should have taken Nick DeLeon he is fast as hell.

our service to the front men was not as good as it could be.

Garza ain’t gonna help that much only 4 assists at the collegiate level. UCSB’s outside backs had more assists. Most outside backs drafted by MLS teams had more assists than that. It’s a really poor figure.

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Jan 13, 2012 5:04 PM PST reply actions  

On the surface, I wanted to see the Quakes draft a defender,

but they defied what I thought was the most deficient position on the roster and made an alternate decision. In both Garza and Hustedt, the Quakes went with speed, pure and simple. While I disagree that those selections were outright mistakes, I can see the selection of a goalkeeper at #33 being suspect. However, the Quakes will be looking to develop a third ‘keeper for the future, and taking a flier on Blais could pay off. At the least, he will provide a good measuring stick to put up against talented academy guys Guzman and McIntosh, either of which has a great chance of becoming San Jose’s first home grown signing. With all the rated centerbacks already selected by that time, going with Blais was acceptable to me.

by robertjonas on Jan 13, 2012 11:04 PM PST reply actions  

drafting someone purely based on speed is not a good process

that is nuts. it is one good asset but it doesn’t make up for deficiencies in every other ability.

http://itmightbedangerous.blogspot.com/2008/06/draft-review-about-process.html

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Jan 14, 2012 9:58 PM PST up reply actions  

keeper in 2nd round

This was smart. For one all teams keeper three keepers on roster and two Bingham will miss 1 1/2 – 2 months for the Olympics. Now we have a back up during this time.

by Psion on Jan 14, 2012 12:32 PM PST via iPhone app reply actions  

no it was not

how many minutes did our 3rd keeper get last season? 45 in a friendly against west brom

how many did our 2nd keeper get? 120 in the US Open cup.

also, there are many keepers we could have taken in the supplemental rounds who are just as good as Blais like Bryan Rowe from UCLA (8 game shutout streak at one point last season).

Win or lose, we'll always be there for you.

by johnjahafanclub on Jan 14, 2012 10:04 PM PST up reply actions  

90 min more

Bingham played a full 90 in a league match. If our 2nd keeper is going to be gone, Olympics, u want to pick up the best keeper u think u can get.

by Psion on Jan 15, 2012 1:05 PM PST via iPhone app up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The SB Nation blog about the San Jose Earthquakes.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Earthquakes vs. Seattle Sounders FC - Gamethread

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Recent Posts


Managers

Jonas0810_small robertjonas